Good Things Come in Small Packages A Look at Tiny Houses

By Kim Gifford

Pick up almost any contemporary decorating or building magazine from Better Homes and Gardens to Country Living to Fine Homebuilding and you will likely find a story on tiny houses. People are using them for home offices, writer’s retreats, guesthouses, homes for returning children or aging parents, and perhaps most incredible of all in this age of “bigger is better” — their primary residences. The possibilities are really limitless, “there are so many different uses for these tiny houses,” says Patricia Foreman who along with her partner Andy Lee runs the Tiny House Company, LLC in Buena Vista, VA and wrote A Tiny Home To Call Your Own.

Definition of Tiny Houses

What constitutes a tiny house? Foreman characterizes small houses as those between 1,000 and 500 square feet and tiny houses as 500 to 120 square feet. Yet, the definition of a tiny house seems open to interpretation. In her book, Not So Big Houses, Sarah Susanka wrote about homes that were over 2,000 to 3,000 square feet. David Howard, a Walpole, NH architect who produces FirstDay Cottages — house kits designed to be constructed by a novice over 15 weekends of intensive labor — feels that “tiny” may not be an appropriate word. He talks about small houses and little houses, but mostly he talks about houses designed to accommodate the way we live.

“One of the things I’ve learned is everyone really spends 99% of their time where hopefully there’s a woodstove and a dining room table and cooking area and a couch, and if that can be set up so that anyone whose doing anything can talk to each other then the room is a great success,” he says. “Then you realize that that space probably needs to be 16 feet by 20 feet and that’s only 320 square feet. Add a couple of bedrooms and a bathroom and that’s under 1,000 square feet. That’s where we really live.”

Perhaps Jay Shafer, owner of Tumbleweed Tiny House Company, offers the most comprehensive definition. He defines a tiny house as dependent on the person. “An oversized house is based on all the space that doesn’t get used. I never try to say what a small house is because it is determined by the individual’s needs — whatever meets the occupant’s needs without exceeding them,” he concludes.

History of Tiny Houses

Among some of the more famous tiny houses are Thomas Jefferson’s honeymoon cabin at Monticello and Henry David Thoreau’s 150 square-foot writer’s retreat at Walden Pond. Although tiny houses have populated the American landscape since the days of the early settlers, many attribute their renewed interest to architect Les Walker who began writing about them in the late 1980s. Yet, Howard notes there was a strong interest in small houses a decade earlier during the energy crunch of the 1970s.

“I figured if in dreary, damp England they can not only do this, but make the house so elegant it’s worth tearing down and bringing to the United States, why can’t we do something like that?”

“One of the most popular books ever about housing came right at the end of the energy crunch when the children of the sixties were finally getting enough money to talk about their own homes,” he says.

Howard refers to 30 Energy-Efficient Homes… You Can Build by Alex Wade and Neal Ewenstein. This book, which underscores the sustainable nature of small houses, features one of Howard’s own tiny homes, which he built in Alstead, NH in the 1970s. This house was only 489 square feet, yet Howard and his wife lived in it for seven years, raising two children there.

“It is still the model for the idea that you live with extraordinary dignity in a very small house,” he says.

Tiny houses are certainly not an American concept. In fact, as Howard notes “the rest of the world does not live in 1,600 square foot houses. They live in little apartments or huts or hovels. You could take a 480 square foot house and nine out of 10 people in the world would consider it the most luxurious thing they could imagine living in.”

Even here in U.S. cities, people live in small studio apartments that they pay thousands of dollars a month for, he continues. In Europe, tiny houses and cottages are common. In fact, in the eighties, Howard was involved in a joint venture with a European firm to take down 20 buildings in England and reconstruct them here in the United States. This project instigated one of the guiding principles of his FirstDay cottages — that they be able to last 500 years.

“I figured if in dreary, damp England they can not only do this, but make the house so elegant it’s worth tearing down and bringing to the United States, why can’t we do something like that?” he says.

The Case for Tiny Houses

The reasons for choosing a tiny house are myriad.

“We don’t want to bash big houses, that’s not our message, but smaller houses can provide niche housing for people whose lifestyles warrant it,”says Foreman.

Environmental

Tiny houses use fewer natural resources to build and produce less construction waste. They require less energy to heat and cool and take up less land.

“It’s a natural extension to think smaller when you consider how we as a nation or a culture or a planet use water and heat and all the resources that go into houses,” confirms Foreman.

Economics

Tiny houses do contain most of the features of a large house, thus, the cost to build them per square foot is typically higher. Yet, since they have less square footage overall, their total cost is less than a large home. The cost to build a tiny house as with larger ones varies greatly from house to house. Among the houses Foreman’s company produces is a 10-foot x 22-foot cabin known as the Copper Top, which sells for approximately $25,000. It features a copper roof, bay window, octagon window, white cedar shingles, window boxes, Anderson Thermopane windows, doors with screens, and a sleeping loft. In addition to a shower, toilet and lavoratory, it has a 12-gallon hot water heater and is fully wired and plumbed. The kitchen features a double bowl sink, under-counter refrigerator, microwave oven, cabinets and pantry.

Jay Shafer’s Tumbleweed Tiny House Company offers even smaller houses. His 100 square-foot, “Emerson,” which features two gothic windows, a cathedral ceiling, vented sleeping loft for two, retractable table and vanity, more than 200 cubic feet for storage, a double burner, shower, toilet, six-gallon water heater, a stainless steel counter, refrigerator and sink, starts at around $14,000.

“You can put more money into the quality of the house because you are spending less on quantity,” concludes Shafer, who recently sold his 100-square foot house to build one that is 7 foot by 10 foot.

“I have everything I need,” he says. This includes a 4-foot by 1.5-foot desk, a tiny kitchen, and a couch for two, as well as a lot of storage.

Howard’s First Day Cottages, many of which are under 1,000 square feet, cost less than $40,000 to build.

“The most important thing to understand is that most people are not doing this because they are poor. They are doing this because they want to be rich,” says Howard. “If you can build your own house for $40,000 on a piece of land you paid $20,000 for, with an infrastructure you paid $20,000 and you get into the house for $80,000 then you are rich. If you pay $160,000 for a run-down piece of junk, you are poor.”

Lifestyle Choice

Many people choose tiny houses for personal reasons. Shafer, for example, grew up in a big house. “I just don’t want to deal with all the extra stuff that I don’t need, including the extra space that has to be heated and cleaned,” he says.

“Fifty-seven percent of American households are single-head of the house with one or at the most two people living in them, so why are we building these standard three bedroom, two bath, 2,500 square feet and up houses, when most of us don’t need that big of a place on that much land?” asks Foreman.

All too frequently, houses are designed with wasted space, says Robert Haight, an architect in Windsor, VT. “Tiny houses just make too much sense.”

Considerations

All the experts agree that those considering a tiny house weigh their needs, eliminating as much frivolous space as possible and come up with a good business plan. Shafer says guests who visit his tiny house, typically think its great.

“They start thinking and conclude ‘I can do this,’ or they think it’s great, but realize they can’t. Most people haven’t had time to think about what their spatial needs are and their needs in general. A house really exemplifies and embodies all our material needs,” he says.